"The Church must breathe with both lungs!" declared a recent pope. Pope Bonaventure, though, appears to disagree with his predecessor. In the leaked encyclical, Quarto Pulmonarum, the Holy Father lays out a new vision of ecclesial understanding, proclaiming, "The Church must breathe with four lungs!"
"It is an injustice to the Church's holy traditions to divide them so brusquely," writes the Successor of Peter. "Let us not say there is only an East and a West: let us say there is an Greek, and an Oriental, and a Roman, and a German." The Pope's schema views the traditions as divided among what are now the Eastern Orthodox, Oriental Orthodox, Roman Catholic, and Protestants (other Catholics, it is assumed, are placed with their respective traditions).
Many say the view is absurd, yet there are two opposing parties. For instance, canonist Gratian Ordelli complains that this is too much division. "We should love distinction, but only such distinction as is true. These distinctions seem to be just trying to give minority groups and heretics 'warm and fuzzies' by saying they're special parts of the Church. The Church only has two lungs, just like any other body: any more and She's a monster." Preacher Ed Shepherd of the Seventy-Third Evangelical Church of West Alaska is of the opposite view: "There are still so many traditions that are not represented. Where is the Methodist lung, the Calvinist lung, the Lutheran lung, the West Alaskan Evangelical lung? We all have worthy traditions within the invisible Church. I'll never join the papists if they won't take my views seriously."
However, the hullabaloo over the encyclical may be completely baseless. Proclamations from the Vatican Public Relations Office define, "No encyclical is rendered official until it is printed on the electronic parchment of the Vatican website. Our web design is an official part of Vatican document approval." Since the document was leaked on the Facebook page "♥♥♥!!!wE ♥ PoPe bONAvenTOoR!!♥♥♥(:" as a painfully-laid-out WordPerfect file, it seems to not be authenticated by the Vatican yet. "Besides, Pope Bonaventure has never divided the Church into more than two lungs," reminded the Vatican. "Why would he start now?"
We won't know for certain about Pope Bonaventure's views on this subject, or even if there is an encyclical in progress on this topic, until he personally makes a statement about it...which, with the recent ban on social media in the Vatican, might not be for a long time.
"It is an injustice to the Church's holy traditions to divide them so brusquely," writes the Successor of Peter. "Let us not say there is only an East and a West: let us say there is an Greek, and an Oriental, and a Roman, and a German." The Pope's schema views the traditions as divided among what are now the Eastern Orthodox, Oriental Orthodox, Roman Catholic, and Protestants (other Catholics, it is assumed, are placed with their respective traditions).
Many say the view is absurd, yet there are two opposing parties. For instance, canonist Gratian Ordelli complains that this is too much division. "We should love distinction, but only such distinction as is true. These distinctions seem to be just trying to give minority groups and heretics 'warm and fuzzies' by saying they're special parts of the Church. The Church only has two lungs, just like any other body: any more and She's a monster." Preacher Ed Shepherd of the Seventy-Third Evangelical Church of West Alaska is of the opposite view: "There are still so many traditions that are not represented. Where is the Methodist lung, the Calvinist lung, the Lutheran lung, the West Alaskan Evangelical lung? We all have worthy traditions within the invisible Church. I'll never join the papists if they won't take my views seriously."
However, the hullabaloo over the encyclical may be completely baseless. Proclamations from the Vatican Public Relations Office define, "No encyclical is rendered official until it is printed on the electronic parchment of the Vatican website. Our web design is an official part of Vatican document approval." Since the document was leaked on the Facebook page "♥♥♥!!!wE ♥ PoPe bONAvenTOoR!!♥♥♥(:" as a painfully-laid-out WordPerfect file, it seems to not be authenticated by the Vatican yet. "Besides, Pope Bonaventure has never divided the Church into more than two lungs," reminded the Vatican. "Why would he start now?"
We won't know for certain about Pope Bonaventure's views on this subject, or even if there is an encyclical in progress on this topic, until he personally makes a statement about it...which, with the recent ban on social media in the Vatican, might not be for a long time.